Sugar Bae Cafe
Custom Cakes
for Every Celebration
Made fresh to order with premium ingredients — each cake is carefully crafted to match your vision and make your celebration unforgettable.
Customer Favorites
Trending Cakes at Sugar Bae
Some of our most popular cakes are inspired by trending desserts and rich, indulgent flavors — perfect for celebrations and stunning centerpieces.
Dubai Chocolate Cake
Pistachio cream and crispy kataifi layers
Chocolate Loaded Celebration
Topped with Ferrero, Kinder, Cadbury & Pocky
Pistachio Cream Cake
Finished with pistachio glaze
Biscoff Cake
Layered with lotus cream and cookie crumble
Mango Tres Leches
Topped with fresh mango
Signature Cake Flavors
Choose from our rich and popular flavors — custom flavor requests are always welcome.
Chocolate Fudge
Triple Chocolate
Vanilla Bean
Red Velvet
Tres Leches
Mango Tres Leches
Pistachio Cream
Nutella Chocolate
Biscoff
Dubai Chocolate with Pistachio & Kataifi
Playful & Delicious
Kids Birthday Cakes
Make your child's birthday extra special with a fun and colorful custom cake designed to be playful, exciting, and delicious.
Rich & Indulgent
Luxury Chocolate Cakes
For true chocolate lovers — rich, indulgent, and beautifully decorated. Layers of moist chocolate sponge paired with premium fillings and elegant decorations.
Premium Fillings:
Perfect for birthdays, anniversaries, and special celebrations.
Order a Luxury CakePerfect for Every Occasion
Each cake can be customized with your colors, theme, message, and decorations — designed to make your celebration unforgettable.
Birthday Celebrations
Weddings & Engagements
Baby Showers
Graduations
Corporate Events
Luxury Dessert Tables
Our Latest Creations
Take a look at some of our recent custom cakes for inspiration.
Cake Sizes & Pricing
Our cakes are available in multiple sizes depending on the number of guests. If you're unsure what size to order, we'll help guide you based on your guest count.
Small Cakes
Perfect for intimate celebrations
Medium Cakes
Ideal for birthdays and small gatherings
Large Cakes
Great for parties and events
Starting at $75
Final pricing depends on cake size, design complexity, and specialty toppings or decorations.
Contact Us for a Custom QuoteHow to Order
Custom cakes require advance notice so we can prepare and design them properly. When placing an order, please include the following information:
Serving Long Island & Nassau County
Sugar Bae proudly creates custom cakes for customers across Long Island including:
Order Today
Let Sugar Bae Make Your Celebration Sweeter
Every cake at Sugar Bae is made fresh, decorated by hand, and designed to make your celebration unforgettable. We look forward to creating something beautiful for your next event.
Order Your Custom Cake Today